A Gathering of Shadows by V.E. Schwab || A Review by Cody R. Whaley
11/14/2026

★★★★★ — 5/5 Stars
I really enjoyed A Darker Shade of Magic, but I did mention in my review that toward the end, it kind of lost me. It started covering too much ground too quickly and, frankly, lost the sauce. It felt unresolved. And yes, it's a series. Of course things are going to feel unresolved. But there was something strange about it. It genuinely felt like a much longer book that V.E. Schwab was told to condense down into something smaller.
A Gathering of Shadows did not feel that way.
I think book two is exponentially better in almost every way.
First and foremost, I gotta say, WE GOT A TOURNAMENT ARC. That's all I need, baby. A tournament arc. Fantastic. We've also got pirates. We've got gay pirates. I mean, all pirates are gay, so we're checking a lot of boxes here.
But what I really loved about this book is that we've fallen into this wonderful category of fantasy that I absolutely adore. There's no massive, world-ending catastrophe driving every little thing our characters do. They're living their lives. Their elevated, fantastical lives, sure. They're casting spells in arenas and doing all sorts of ridiculous magical nonsense, but they're living. There's no crazy, looming threat constantly watering down the adventure. And I love that.
This book made me want to be here. It made me want to explore this world, particularly Red London. I wanted to wander its streets, learn about its people, and just exist in this fantastical place for a while. That's something I don't think the first book quite accomplished.
But all this brings up a few concerns.
I'm starting to wonder what exactly we're going to do for book three.
This is a trilogy, after all, and while I'm absolutely enjoying myself, I can't help but worry that we're heading toward some shoehorned-in villain who's going to suddenly become everyone's problem.
The first book didn't exactly leave us with some grand mystery about who might be lurking in the shadows. This book starts to introduce that idea, particularly toward the end, but it all feels a little... sudden?
Are we just going to pull some big evil bastard out of our ass for the third book? Maybe. And that's what I'm worried about.
The ending introduces an antagonist we know next to nothing about, with very little established lore to give that threat any real weight. It's also an absolute cliffhanger that leads directly into the next book. And while I'm intrigued, I'm also a little skeptical.
Is this going to be a villain for the sake of having a villain? Some random evil guy doing evil things so our heroes can come together and defeat him? I certainly hope not.
It makes me wonder whether the trilogy as a whole might have benefited from being paced differently. Maybe some of this book should have been in book one. Maybe some of book three should have been introduced here. I don't know yet, obviously, but I can already feel myself worrying about how all of this is going to come together.
And that's the funny thing. Despite all these concerns, I genuinely think A Gathering of Shadows deserves five stars.
I had a fantastic time with this book. It gave me wonderful characters, a world I desperately wanted to spend more time in, pirates, magic, and a godsdamned tournament arc. What more could I ask for?
I'm absolutely moving on to book three. I'm excited to see where this all goes.
I just really, really hope we don't end up with some slapped-together villain and a rushed conclusion to a world I've finally fallen in love with.
-Review by Cody R. Whaley
Cody R. Whaley
Contact
GOBLIN KVLT Newsletter
crwhaley.books@gmail.com
© 2024. All rights reserved.
